Mascaras for Sensitive Eyes That Say Goodbye to Irritation

When asked about their favorite makeup products by makeup experts, lovers, or even a girl that loves doing and trying new makeup, almost 99% of the people say “Mascara”. Just like the trend we were spotting all over the internet and in real life, where only one product can make a big change and no makeup can actually look as cool as any other makeup look. While when people decide to buy a mascara and get them one they often complain about mascaras being smudged, ruined, greasy, and the worst symptoms are feeling irritation in eyes. While avoiding smudged mascara, you can go for waterproof mascaras but for non-irritant eyes, it's so difficult to find the right mascara sometimes.

Well, not anymore. There are tons of great options out there in the market these days, from drugstore options to top skincare brands that we can’t live without. The best thing is while they are non-irritant, they are also infused with a lot of hydrating and moisturizing ingredients which is a win-win and does the double job for us. While I was getting a lot of questions about how I am wearing a mascara when I have sensitive eyes and I actually stopped using Mascara sometimes ago because I was facing the same. I had to do research to find the best mascaras for sensitive eyes for everyone struggling out there. So, let’s get right into it.

Mascaras for Sensitive Eyes That Actually Works

From our favorite TikTok skincare brand Glossier’s Mascara to the brand that blessed us with the best sunscreen and that’s La Roche-Posay, let me walk you through some of the best mascaras for sensitive eyes for everybody out there.

ILIA Limitless Lash Mascara

ILIA is a well know beauty brand in the industry which is known for clean and effective products, and their limitless lash mascara is no exception. This mascara has won Glamour Beauty Award in 2019 and Allure Beauty Award in 2020, so when I came across this I knew this mascara will worth it. While testing this out I got to know that the limitless lash mascara is extremely lightweight that you will feel like you are wearing nothing on your lashes but at the same time this will give your lashes thick and lengthy effect without irritating your eyes. The best thing is this mascara is free of any harsh ingredients and it contains organic Bee and Carnauba waxes which helps in conditioning your lashes and the organic shea butter in it helps your lashes to enhance without clumsy and messy feel.

Milk Makeup KUSH Waterproof Mascara

You know what impressed me the most about this mascara, it’s ability to stay put even in the worst humidity and saddest day with a bucket of tears. It never disappoints me on a rainy day even, it was raining lightly but still rain is rain. It doesn't smudge and gives the perfect curl effect to your lashes that every girl dreams of. It’s that product that delivers what it claims, stays put till the end of the day. Also this mascara does not contain any harsh ingredients, one of the best vegan mascara for sensitive eyes that does not irritate eyes. And you know what this mascara is rich with all the conditioning and moisturizing ingredients like hemp-derived cannabis sativa seed oil which is great for keeping your lashes healthy and lengthy from inside out.

Twenty/Twenty Clean Sweep Mascara

If you are a clean beauty fan then without a doubt this brand should be in your beauty bag (if not yet). The Clean Sweep mascara is as clean and vegan as its name and let me tell you how. The brand claims that this mascara is developed and tested by Ophthalmologist and even eye care professionals agreed on clean sweep mascara being completely safe for sensitive eyes. The mascara is infused with such hydrating and nourishing ingredients like hyaluronic acid, vitamin E, and biotin, we all know how great these ingredients for our lashes. You can wear this mascara everyday as its lightweight, suitable for irritated and sensitive eyes, and doesn’t clump your lashes as its waterproof.

Eye Want You Mascara

For an all-in-one solution, this mascara is a must-have. It excels in lengthening, volumizing, and defining lashes, all while remaining buildable and free from flakes—whether you opt for a single swipe or three. The innovative formula lives up to every promise, and its ease of removal with warm water ensures my eyes stay comfortable and irritation-free before bedtime.

Clinique High Impact Mascara

Experience the gentle touch of Clinique's high-impact mascara, free from irritation. Suitable for day or night wear, especially when complemented by a neutral eyeshadow. With a notable 4.3-star average from nearly 2,800 Sephora reviews, it's evident that this mascara is a favorite. As a dedicated Clinique makeup user since high school, this mascara stands out as one of their must-have products.

For those prone to watery eyes, this mascara is a game-changer. Despite experimenting with other brands promising drama or volume, Clinique remains the only mascara that keeps my lashes looking their best—long, full, and dramatic.

La Roche-PosayToleriane Waterproof Mascara

Venture into the world of French pharmacy expertise with this mascara. Crafted for sensitive skin, it delivers fluffy lashes resistant to rain and tears. Enriched with moisturizing panthenol, it ensures your lashes remain flexible and comfortable. The waterproof formula guarantees steadfast wear, though the brand recommends a bi-phase eye makeup remover for easy removal at the end of the day.

Clean Lash Lengthening Tubing Mascara

If clumpy lashes are a concern, the Merit mascara is your solution. Its innovative formula and uniquely shaped wand work together to separate and define each lash. Achieve a fluttery and soft look with a high-impact, uber-black pigment. For everyday wear, a single quick application suffices, but for added length, two coats are easily buildable without flaking.

Beautycounter Think Big All-in-One Mascara

The Think Big mascara has won Southern Living Beauty Awards in 2021, and scored 4.6 stars with 4188 reviews which instantly clear the doubts of anyone who is having second thoughts about this mascara. This clean mascara is infused with provitamin B5 and tripetide which helps condition the lashes, while rica barn and carnauba wax gives a weightless feel and make the lashes looks fuller, and the black pigment added in this mascara provides the perfect black color that is free of carbon. Lastly, it is smudge proof and stay put for long so you can trust this one to stay from day to night without messing up your makeup look.

Perricone MD No Makeup Mascara with Biotin

Ideal for those with sensitive eyes, this product is more than just a mascara—it's a versatile 2-in-1 lash treatment. Formulated with neuropeptides and biotin, it not only enhances the thickness and fullness of your eyelashes but also strengthens them. The mascara itself is remarkable, providing impressive lifting and lengthening effects. Customize your look, opting for a subtle or dramatic outcome by adjusting the number of layers applied.

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Waterproof Mascara

The highly acclaimed waterproof mascara gained viral status for a reason—it adds remarkable length even to the shortest lashes. Its ophthalmologist-tested waterproof formulation ensures that even those with sensitive eyes can enjoy its dramatic results. Say goodbye to flaking, smudging, or eye irritation, as this mascara delivers the same lash-lifting finish consistently.

Glossier Lash Slick Mascara

Inside the cute pink packaging comes a mascara wand with tiny fibers which helps perfectly cover each and every lash without giving clumsy and messy mascara effect. The best thing ever is this mascara is completely fragrance free which automatically makes it a must have for sensitive eyes. But that’s not it guys, there is more, you cannot believe that this mascara is tried and tested on contact lenses and they are as good as ever. The weightless feel is just unmatched to any other mascara I ever owned in my life. Lastly, It has a tubing formula that helps in smooth removal of the mascara without rubbing and getting your eyes irritated.

What To Consider When Buying Mascaras For Sensitive Eyes

When choosing a perfect mascara for sensitive eyes, here are some essential concerns to keep in mind:

• Is It Hypoallergenic: If you are a beauty enthusiast you must have been aware of this or at least found this term written on many skincare products. It’s actually a proof of the product being non-irritant so you can easily buy and use the product. These terms can also be named as “hypoallergenic”, “clinically-approved”, and “dermatologically-tested” and so on. Make sure the product you buy whether its a mascara or anything, has one of these terms.
• Is The Brand Trustable: Whatever brand’s product you are getting for yourself, make sure the brand has a good reputation in the industry so you know you will be using the product that is made right and free of any harsh ingredients and irritants.
• Is It Fragrance-Free: We hear it all the time when it comes to skincare products, because it is actually really important to do so. You should always check your mascaras if they are fragrance free and free of all the natural extracts like beeswax, carbon black, nickel, lanolin as they can also trigger allergies.
• Is It Waterproof: While so many of us love a waterproof mascara as no one wants a smudgy mascara, black eyes, and watery eyes but let me reveal a side effect of this as they can be extremely harmful for your eyes. They are difficult to remove so they are also a bit harmful so avoid rubbing eyes if you use it or just go with other mascaras.

Conclusion

So, these are the best mascaras for sensitive eyes that finally stop your struggle to find the mascara that does not cause redness, irritation, and allergies in your eyes. All these mascaras are either from the top brands that are loved by celebrities or the ones that are all over TikTok by the womens who love wearing them all day long. Try these out and have a care-free mascara day!